Module 4 · Lesson
From heat rate to a generator offer
- 30 minutes
- Intermediate
- Editorial status: Phase 1 Complete
- Market-neutral + ERCOT case
Market question. If natural gas trades at $3.50/MMBtu, what should a gas generator cost to run—and is that necessarily the price it offers into the market?
Step 1
Translate efficiency into marginal fuel cost
A thermal generator's heat rate measures fuel energy consumed per unit of electrical output, commonly Btu/kWh or MMBtu/MWh. The unit conversion changes the number by a factor of 1,000: 7 MMBtu/MWh equals 7,000 Btu/kWh, because one MMBtu is 1,000,000 Btu and one MWh is 1,000 kWh. A lower heat rate means greater conversion efficiency. Multiplying heat rate by delivered fuel price gives a marginal fuel-cost estimate. Adding variable operations and maintenance gives a compact short-run production-cost model.
MC = heat rate × delivered fuel price + variable O&MUnits provide the first audit:
MMBtu/MWh × $/MMBtu = $/MWhFuel price must be aligned to the generator's location and delivery terms. A benchmark hub price may omit basis, transport, imbalance, and timing effects. Heat rate can also vary with output, ambient conditions, degradation, and start state. A single value is an approximation, not a complete operating curve.
Step 2
Calculate and compare two units
Worked example
Two gas units facing the same fuel price
Assume synthetic Unit A has a 7 MMBtu/MWh heat rate, $3.50/MMBtu delivered gas, and $4/MWh variable O&M:
Apply the mechanism
Calculate Unit A's marginal production cost from a 7 MMBtu/MWh heat rate, $3.50/MMBtu delivered gas, and $4/MWh variable O&M.
Synthetic Unit B faces the same fuel and variable O&M but has a 9.5 MMBtu/MWh heat rate:
Apply the mechanism
Calculate Unit B's marginal production cost from a 9.5 MMBtu/MWh heat rate, $3.50/MMBtu delivered gas, and $4/MWh variable O&M.
Unit B costs $8.75/MWh more at the margin. The difference is entirely the extra 2.5 MMBtu/MWh of fuel multiplied by $3.50/MMBtu. The comparison holds other relevant conditions constant.
- Fuel
- $24.50/MWh
- Variable O&M
- $4.00/MWh
- Emissions
- $8.00/MWh
The figure exposes an optional emissions-cost term so you can inspect a broader cost formulation. For the required $28.50/MWh calculation, use only fuel and variable O&M. Any emissions price, allowance opportunity cost, or other adder must be identified separately rather than silently folded into the number.
Pause and predict
At the same delivered fuel price and variable O&M, which change raises marginal production cost most directly?
Step 3
Stress the cost and separate it from the offer
Fuel exposure is proportional to heat rate. For Unit A, a $1/MMBtu increase in delivered gas raises the simple marginal-cost estimate by $7/MWh. The higher-heat-rate Unit B rises by $9.50/MWh. This differential sensitivity can change unit ordering as fuel conditions move.
- Fuel
- $42.00/MWh
- Variable O&M
- $4.00/MWh
- Emissions
- $8.00/MWh
An offer is a market submission governed by the applicable tariff, protocols, mitigation rules, and resource constraints. It need not equal the simple marginal production-cost estimate. Relevant omitted considerations can include:
- start-up and no-load costs, minimum run time, minimum output, ramp limits, and multi-period commitment tradeoffs;
- fuel-delivery constraints, imbalance exposure, emissions allowances, consumables, and output-dependent efficiency;
- opportunity costs, including foregone value in another interval or product, where permitted and appropriately reflected;
- uncertainty about fuel, availability, load, renewable output, and dispatch; and
- market-specific offer formats, mitigation, make-whole payments, and other rule-defined treatments.
This is not a license to infer strategic intent from the gap between cost and offer. First confirm measurement conventions, operating constraints, and market rules.
Average cost is not marginal cost
Fixed capital recovery and annual fixed O&M matter for investment economics, but they do not automatically enter the short-run cost of producing one additional MWh. Conversely, a unit may incur lumpy commitment costs that the one-line marginal formula misses. Keep the question—dispatch, commitment, or investment—explicit.
Apply the mechanism
Identify at least two operational or opportunity considerations omitted from the simple marginal-cost formula, and explain how each could make an offer differ from that estimate.
Takeaways
- Heat rate converts a fuel price into a per-MWh fuel cost; dimensional analysis catches many errors.
- At $3.50/MMBtu gas, the synthetic 7-heat-rate unit costs $28.50/MWh and the 9.5-heat-rate unit costs $37.25/MWh before separately identified adders.
- Fuel-price sensitivity equals heat rate in $/MWh per $/MMBtu.
- Offers are rule-governed commercial submissions; modeled costs are analytical estimates. Treating them as identical discards operational, temporal, and institutional information.
Selected sources
Sources and model boundaries
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: What is the heat rate of electric power generation?Retrieved 2026-08-03.
Heat rate is an efficiency measure, not a complete representation of a generator offer or dispatch cost.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Electricity prices and factors affecting pricesRetrieved 2026-08-03.
Explains retail and wholesale price factors at a high level rather than a real-time price-setting formula.
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission: Understanding Energy MarketsRetrieved 2026-08-03.
High-level market-design context; regional implementation details vary by organized market.